In response to "Are We Overlooking Homicidal Ideation in Psychiatry?" by Jordyn Tovey1COMMENT: Thank you for your article. I have just two thoughts regarding issues that were not raised.
1) I know that in America, confidentiality can no longer be assumed to be operative in conversations with a “professional,” whether we’re talking about a conversation with a priest or a psychiatrist. This creates an uncertain climate for the “patient.” They will be less likely to be honest about their anger precisely to the extent that they “plan to do something about it.”
2) There are a class of drugs called entheogens, which includes MDMA. America has been too busy hating drugs to notice that such drugs help inspire compassion. In a sane world, surely we would be using entheogens in counseling sessions to help angry patients “feel” for their perceived enemies.
The use of Ecstasy (the street version of MDMA) in the British rave scene of the 1990s resulted in unprecedented peace on the dance floor. Unprecedented! But MPs cracked down on the drug, and dancers switched to alcohol, a drug that kills 178,000 a year in the US alone. After the crackdown, the dance floors erupted into violence, all “justified” by the fact that a few young people had died after using Ecstasy. Why? Because drug prohibition had denied them regulated product and information about safe use.
These are drugs that help people feel compassion! Surely, this is hugely relevant to the topic of counseling angry patients. Consider the following quotations from DJs in Britain, as they describe the peaceful 1990s rave scene that existed with the help of Ecstasy. The following quotes are from the 2020 documentary by Terry Stone entitled “United Nation: Three Decades of Drum & Bass.”
“It was the first time that black-and-white people had integrated on a level… and everybody was one.” — DJ Ray Keith.
“It was black and white, Asian, Chinese, all up in one building.” — DJ MC GQ.
“Everyone’s loving each other, man, they’re not hating.” – DJ Mampi Swift.
And MDMA is just one of endless phenethylamines that could exist in a free world. Chemist Alexander Shulgin had the rare freedom to synthesize hundreds of phenethylamines in the 1990s, resulting in user reports such as the following:
“The feeling was one of great camaraderie, and it was very easy to talk to people.”
“I was able to go through and resolve some judgments with particular persons.”
“No more axes to grind. I can be free.”
Drugs like opium and cocaine should come with the following warning: "Outlawing of this product may result in inner-city gunfire, civil wars overseas, and rigged elections in which drug warriors win office by throwing minorities in jail."
If we encourage folks to use antidepressants daily, there is nothing wrong with them using heroin daily. A founder of Johns Hopkins used morphine daily and he not only survived, but he thrived.
Americans think that fighting drugs is more important than freedom. We have already given up on the fourth amendment. Nor is the right to religion honored for those who believe in indigenous medicines. Pols are now trying to end free speech about drugs as well.
It is consciousness which, via perception, shapes the universe into palpable forms. Otherwise it's just a chaos of particles. The very fact that you can refer to "the sun" shows that your senses have parsed the raw data into a specific meaning. "We" make this universe.
I should have added to that last post: "I in no way want to glorify or condone drug demonization."
The healthcare industry turns all the emotional downsides of drug prohibition into "illnesses."
Even if the FDA approved MDMA today, it would only be available for folks specifically pronounced to have PTSD by materialist doctors, as if all other emotional issues are different problems and have to be studied separately. That's just ideological foot-dragging.
Whether we judge people only by the words that they say or only by the substances of which they partake, we are ignoring the most important things: what they really mean and how they really behave.
In America, they save the depressed from cocaine and opium by turning them into patients for life with dependence-causing "meds." Now 30-year-old doctors get to treat 67-year-olds like children, with new visits every damn three months.
Americans heap hypocritical praise on Walt Whitman. What they don't realize is that many of us could be "Walt Whitman for a Day" with the wise use of psychoactive drugs. To the properly predisposed, morphine gives a DEEP appreciation of Mother Nature.
(up)